Andy’s Frozen Custard – Full Menu with Prices
Welcome to Andy’s Frozen Custard menu, where every treat is crafted with rich, creamy frozen custard made fresh hourly. From classic sundaes and concretes to seasonal specialties, Andy’s offers a delicious variety of desserts, each packed with flavor and made with high-quality ingredients. Whether you prefer vanilla or chocolate custard, you can customize your treat with a wide range of toppings and mix-ins. Indulge in a smooth, velvety texture and a taste that keeps customers coming back for more. Explore the menu and find your perfect frozen delight today!
Andy’s Concretes are a thick, creamy blend of frozen custard and your favorite mix-ins, creating a smooth, spoonable treat. Made fresh with high-quality ingredients, each Concrete is customizable with a variety of toppings, from fruit and nuts to candies and cookies. Try a classic favorite or create your own perfect combination!
BootDaddy
$5.89 | Small
The BootDaddy Concrete features rich vanilla custard blended with Oreo cookies, crème caramel and hot fudge.
Triple Chocolate
$4.64 | Small
The Triple Chocolate Concrete is a rich, creamy frozen custard blended with chocolate syrup, brownie pieces and chocolate chunks.
Ooye Gooey
$4.48 | Small
The Ooye Gooey is a specific flavour of frozen custard blended with almonds, crème caramel and Heath Bar.
Snowmonster
$4.64 | Small
The Snowmonster is a rich creamy frozen custard combined with melted chocolate chips and strawberries .
Butter Pecan
$4.84 | Small
The Butter Pecan is a rich creamy frozen custard blended with roasted pecans and butter scotch.
Mint Chip
$4.64 | Small
The Mint Chip is frozen custard blended with melted chocolate chips and mint syrup.
Jitterbug
$4.64 | Small
Andy’ Jitterbud is a chocolate or vanilla custard blended with almonds, Heath Bar and espresso.
Strawberry and Oreo
$3.89 | Small
Andy’s Strawberry and Oreo is a rich chocolate or vanilla frozen custard blended with Oreos and strawberries to
Choc-o-Rocko
$ 3.89| Small
The Choco-o-Rocko is creamy frozen custard blended with marshmallow crème and almonds.
Cherry Bash
$5.39 | Small
The Cherry Bash is frozen custard combined with maraschino cherries, chocolate syrup and almonds and Heath Bar.
JACKHAMMERS
Andy’s Concretes are a thick, creamy blend of frozen custard and your favorite mix-ins, creating a smooth, spoonable treat. Made fresh with high-quality ingredients, each Concrete is customizable with a variety of toppings, from fruit and nuts to candies and cookies. Try a classic favorite or create your own perfect combination!
James Brownie Funky Jackhammer
$5.54| Small
Andy’s frozen custard combined with brownies and peanut butter and filed with hot fudge.
Rico Suave Jackhammer
$5.54 | Small
Andy’s chocolate or vanilla frozen custard combined with Oreo and roasted pecans have center filled hot fudge.
The Jackhammer
$4.79 | Small
The Jackhammer is a frozen custard with topping of customers’ choice.
Andy’s Concretes are a thick, creamy blend of frozen custard and your favorite mix-ins, creating a smooth, spoonable treat. Made fresh with high-quality ingredients, each Concrete is customizable with a variety of toppings, from fruit and nuts to candies and cookies. Try a classic favorite or create your own perfect combination!
Andy’s Ozark Turtle Sundae
$5.34 | Small
Andy’s frozen custard is a blend of crème caramel, roasted pecan and hot fudge with a cherry on top
The Original Straw-Ana Sundae
$4.69 | Small
Andy’s delicious and creamy frozen custard covered with sliced banana and strawberries.
Andy’s Hot Fudge Sundae
$4.59 | Small
Andy’s delicious frozen custard has hot fudge and roasted pecans with a cherry on top.
Stolen Brownie Sundae
$5.69 | Small
Andy’s creamy frozen custard and home made brownie covered with hot fudge, roasted pecan and cherry topping.
Tin Roof Sundae
| Small
Andy’s delicious frozen custard covered with Spanish peanuts and chocolate syrup.
Andy’s Concretes are a thick, creamy blend of frozen custard and your favorite mix-ins, creating a smooth, spoonable treat. Made fresh with high-quality ingredients, each Concrete is customizable with a variety of toppings, from fruit and nuts to candies and cookies. Try a classic favorite or create your own perfect combination!
Andy’s Banana Split
$5.79 | Small
Andy’s Banana Split is a delicious and creamy frozen custard with banana covered with delicious strawberries, topped with crushed nuts, marshmallow crème and cherry.
Andy’s Turtle Split
$5.79 | Small
Andy’s rich frozen custard with a whole banana covered with roasted pecans, hot fudge and crème caramel with cherry on top.
Andy’s Concretes are a thick, creamy blend of frozen custard and your favorite mix-ins, creating a smooth, spoonable treat. Made fresh with high-quality ingredients, each Concrete is customizable with a variety of toppings, from fruit and nuts to candies and cookies. Try a classic favorite or create your own perfect combination!
Malts
$3.89 | Small
Andy’s delicious frozen custard combined with malt powder and topping of customer’s choice.
Shakes
$3.89 | Small
Andy’s rich and delicious frozen custard blended with customer’s favorite topping.
Old-Fashioned Freezes
$3.89 | Small
Andy’s creamy frozen custard blended with customer’s choice soda. .
Old-Fashioned Sodas
$3.49 | Small
Andy’s frozen custard scoops combined with syrup of your choice of cheery, chocolate, raspberry strawberry or lime with seltzer.
Floats
$3.49 | Small
Andy’s rich frozen custard scoops with soda poured on the top.
Zarlengo’s Italian Ice
$2.39 | Small
Italian iced tubes flavored with lemon, raspberry or strawberry lemonade.
Bottled Sprecher Soda
$1.99 | Bottle
Creame Soda and Root Beer
Old-Fashioned Sprecher Soda
$1.99 | Small
Root Beer or Cream Soda on top. Brewed in Milwaukee!
Soft Drinks
$1.29 | Small
Coke, Diet Coke or Sprite on top or Bottled.
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea
$1.69 | Small
Sweet, Unsweet, Raspberry, Cherry or Strawberry.
Andy’s Yummy Late
$3.89| Small
Andy’s delicious vanilla or chocolate frozen custard blended with rich espresso, ice and hot crème caramel or fudge of your choice.